SilkyGirl
Funky Eyelight Pencil (Frosty Silver)

Pros: Creamy, Shimmery, inexpensive, pigmented
Cons: Not very waterproof

I use this for my lower waterline. It is very pigmented and creamy, glides on really easily. It is able to stay for about 4-6 hours. However, after that, when my eyes gets watery (due to yawning), it starts to smudge a little (not as bad as L.A. Girls eyeliner).

As seen in the pictures, its colour is very nice metallic and shimmery silver =).

Though it does smudge a little after hours of wearing, it is still a product worth buying as it is inexpensive, and its colour is suitable for lower waterline.

L.A. Girls Eyeliner (Black)

L.A. Girls
Eyeliner (Black)
Price: $5.90

Pros: Inexpensive, pigmented
Cons: Smudges

This was my first black eyeliner. It is pigmented and goes on to skin easily.

However, few hours after application, it will smudge easily. I wore this to my company's Dinner and Dance. As I have oily eyelids, when I sneeze, it smudes from my upper eyelids to my lower eyelids.. giving me "panda" eyes..

I did not use this product again after the incident.

SilkyGirl Long-Wearing Eyeliner

SilkyGirl
Long-Wearing Eyeliner (Black Brown)

 

Pros: Inexpensive, don't require sharpening (convenient), natural, goes onto skin smoothly, pigmented
Cons: None

This is a crayon eyeliner. It goes onto skin easily, and as its name suggests.. It does last for hours without smudging (unlike L.A. Girls eyeliner).

Sharpening is not required as we can turn it out, instead of having to sharpen. It is pigmented and gives a natural and soft line.

This product is worth buying as it is convenient and does a great job.

SilkyGirl Double Intense Gel Eyeliner

SilkyGirl
Double Intense Eyeliner (002 Dark Brown)
Price: $14.90
                                                                                   

Pros: Inexpensive, long wearing, does not smudge easily, packaging, pigmented
Cons: None

Although this is my first gel eyeliner, I think this is a really great product. This product is wisely designed for convenience of its user - the cover for the bottle is also the cover for the brush... (this product consists of 3 parts)... Unlike other gel eyeliners where the brush and bottle are kept separately.

The last picture was taken after 12 hours of wearing.. it did not smudge or fade at all!!! I expected it to fade a bit.. due to its low price.  When using the samples at Watsons, I thought that it will be impossible to draw a fine line with the brush. However, after using it, I realized that it is not difficult at all.. I love the brush as it is able to give a defined and softer line, as compared to liquid eyeliners. The content is easily picked up by the brush and goes on to skin easily.

Dark brown gives a more natural look. However, for more wild and noticeable makeup, black will be more apt.

I will definitely repurchase this product again as it is a cheaper alternative, yet impressive.  I'd like to try pure black when this bottle finishes. =)